What if half your recruitment advertising budget was going to just 13% of your locations?
That is exactly what we uncovered when reviewing the recruitment performance of a large UK childcare group. Of its 127 sponsored nurseries, 17 were taking half of the attraction budget, leaving quieter nurseries short of applicants. The size of the budget was only part of the story, and where that money went mattered far more.
Patterns like this turn up regularly in the multi-site campaigns we review, whether the locations are nurseries, shops, care homes, warehouses or plants. The national plan looks sound from head office: the budget is agreed, the campaigns are live and the dashboard shows a steady flow of applications. A manager at a location in a harder market often has a different story to tell, with the same role open for weeks and shifts covered by agency staff or overtime.
Our experience shows that the same employer, offering the same job at the same salary, can get completely different results from one location to the next. Local labour markets, competition, candidate availability and operational requirements all differ, and a one-size-fits-all national strategy treats them as if they were the same.
What Our Reviews Have Found
The evidence from client data makes the case for planning by location more clearly than any theory:
- Half the budget on 13% of locations: at a UK childcare group, 17 of 127 sponsored nurseries were taking 50% of the attraction budget. Once budget was redistributed by tier, cost per apply start fell by 67%, from £9.38 to £3.09.
- More budget where it was needed least: at a retail client, the easiest shops to hire generated more than four times as many apply starts per job as the hardest, yet received the most spend per job.
- Fewer open roles and a lower cost per hire: re-tiering that retail estate by difficulty to fill contributed to 41% fewer open requisitions and a 29% reduction in cost per hire.
- More completed applications from wider markets: a manufacturer that extended its targeting into commute-weighted secondary markets increased completed applications by 130% and reduced cost per apply start by 54%.
This guide sets out how to build a national recruitment strategy that is informed by local hiring reality. It starts with reading demand and supply by location and grouping locations by how hard they are to fill. The later sections look at how budget can follow hiring need, when a difficult location deserves a campaign of its own and how to measure the plan through to the hire.
Why Volume Hides Variation
Recruitment reporting tends to start with totals, such as applications this month, cost per application across the estate and time to hire for the business as a whole. These figures are useful for spotting trends and for answering the first question finance usually asks, which is whether the overall programme is working.
A total, however, adds the easy locations and the difficult ones together and reports the blend. A healthy national average can make a struggling recruitment strategy look successful, because it says very little about where hiring is getting harder.
How the blend misleads
Locations in large towns with good transport links and plenty of nearby candidates attract applications quickly and cheaply. Their numbers lift the national average, which then becomes the benchmark every other location is judged against.
A rural location, or one competing with three larger employers on the same retail park, will look like an underperformer against that benchmark even when it is doing well for its market.
What the gap looks like in practice
The retail client mentioned above shows how wide the gap can be:
| Easiest shops | Hardest shops | |
| Apply starts per job | 109 | 25 |
| Spend per job | £72.86 | £44.06 |
The locations that needed the least help were receiving the most of it, and nothing in the national figures pointed to a problem.
Why spend drifts towards the easiest locations
Modern recruitment platforms, including those Yoke partners with, are genuinely sophisticated. Where the right data and integrations exist, many can optimise towards qualified candidates, downstream conversions and even hires. They optimise towards the goal they are set, though, and when that goal applies across the whole estate, spend naturally flows towards the locations where candidates respond most readily.
What the platform can’t supply on its own is the business context, such as which locations have the greatest operational need or what an unfilled shift costs at each one. Matching spend to that need is a planning decision, and it belongs to the TA team and the partners who advise them. Our blog on why your national average is hiding your hardest locations explores the planning choices behind this drift.
Start With Demand and Supply, Location by Location
A strong multi-site plan begins with two questions for every location. The first is how many people the location needs to hire, and the second is how easy it is to find them in that particular market.
Demand comes from the business and covers open requisitions, expected turnover by role, planned openings and any seasonal peaks. Operations teams usually hold most of this already, so bringing them into planning early gives TA a hiring forecast that reflects how each location actually runs.
Supply is harder to pin down, because it depends on the local labour market and on how candidates there respond to your jobs. The signals worth gathering for each location include:
- the size of the relevant talent pool within a realistic commute
- the employers competing for the same candidates, and what they pay
- apply starts per job, which shows how readily local candidates respond
- the share of candidates who complete an application and reach interview
- how long roles at the location have typically stayed open
Set side by side, demand and supply turn a single national picture into a map of where hiring is straightforward and where it is hard. Every budget and campaign decision in the rest of this guide builds on that map.
Most of this data already exists across job board dashboards, the applicant tracking system (ATS) and operational reports. The usual difficulty is that it sits in separate systems and has rarely been joined up at location level. A first pass can be rough and still be valuable, and apply starts per job, time to fill and open requisitions by location are normally enough to show where the biggest gaps sit.
Tier Your Locations by Difficulty to Fill
The demand and supply view makes it possible to group locations into tiers according to how hard they are to fill. Most estates settle on three or four tiers, and a four-tier structure typically looks like this:
| Tier | What it looks like | What it usually needs |
| 1. Self-sufficient | Strong candidate response and roles that fill quickly | Light support and a cap on spend |
| 2. Steady | Reliable fills with standard campaign support | Business-as-usual campaigns |
| 3. Stretched | Slower fills, a smaller talent pool or heavier competition | More budget and sharper, local job content |
| 4. Critical | Persistent vacancies with a clear operational cost | A dedicated plan, which may reach beyond media |
The tiers describe how hard each location is to fill, which can be quite different from how large or commercially important it is. A flagship shop in a busy city centre may sit comfortably in tier 1, while a small branch in a market town ends up in tier 4 because the nearest competitor pays more and the last bus leaves before the evening shift ends.
Locations also move between tiers as local conditions change. A new distribution centre opening nearby can push a location from steady to stretched within a month, so a quarterly review of the tiers keeps the plan aligned with what is happening on the ground.
The retail client re-tiered its shops in exactly this way, setting budget to match how hard each one was to fill. That revised approach contributed to 41% fewer open requisitions and a 29% reduction in cost per hire across the estate.
Let Hiring Need Decide Where Budget Goes
Many multi-site campaigns set budget nationally and share it out by headcount or by the number of live jobs. The approach feels fair and is simple to run, yet it assumes every location faces the same market. Tiering gives a far better basis for allocation, because it ties each pound or dollar to how hard the hire is to make.
The childcare group from the start of this guide shows what changes. Once the review had shown 13% of its sponsored nurseries taking half of the attraction budget, the group segmented every nursery into four tiers and redirected budget to the nurseries that had been left short. Cost per apply start fell by 67%, from £9.38 to £3.09, and applicants became evenly spread across the estate.
A few principles help budget follow need in the same way:
- Fund tier 1 locations to maintain their flow of candidates, with caps that stop them absorbing money they don’t need.
- Ring-fence a share of the budget for tier 3 and tier 4 locations, so the natural pull towards easy volume can’t drain it.
- Set targets by tier, since a sensible cost per apply start for a tier 4 location will be higher than for a tier 1 location.
- Review allocation monthly and move money when a location changes tier.
This approach also strengthens the conversation with finance. A vacancy at a tier 4 location usually carries a cost far greater than the media spend needed to fill it, whether that cost shows up as agency cover, overtime, reduced capacity or lost trading hours. Putting a daily cost on those vacancies gives TA a commercial case for investing where hiring is hardest, and it gives finance a way to weigh recruitment spend against the cost of leaving roles open.
When a Hard-to-Fill Location Needs Its Own Campaign
Most locations can share a business-as-usual campaign, with budget and targets set by tier. A small number, however, need more than a bigger share of the national campaign, and separating them into a dedicated campaign gives them their own budget, targeting and job content.
The signals that a location is ready to be separated tend to be consistent:
- It has stayed in the hardest tier for more than a quarter.
- Its vacancies are causing a measurable operational cost.
- The role, pay or shift pattern differs noticeably from the rest of the estate.
- It sits in a market with its own competition, such as a new logistics hub or a hospital cluster.
- Budget keeps flowing to easier locations despite caps within the shared campaign.
A dedicated campaign allows the job content to speak to the local market, with details such as commute, shift times, parking or nearby transport that matter to candidates in that area. It also opens the door to channels the national campaign may not use, from local community groups to targeted social and programmatic activity.
It is worth checking whether media is really the constraint before a location is separated. Pay that sits below the local market, a shift pattern candidates can’t manage or slow follow-up from the location can all hold hiring back, and more spend won’t fix any of them. Yoke diagnoses before prescribing, so a dedicated campaign is reserved for locations where better visibility and local relevance will genuinely make the difference. Our blog on where candidates drop out between application and hire covers the process fixes that often matter just as much.
Separate campaigns also add reporting and optimisation effort. The list of separated locations works best when it stays short, and each campaign should have a clear point at which the location rejoins the main programme.
Look Beyond the Local Talent Pool
Some locations can’t hire enough people from their immediate area, however well the campaign is run. Plants, distribution centres, contact centres and hospitals often sit outside town centres or need more people than the local market can supply, and the answer for these locations is usually to widen the search into secondary markets.
The important detail is weighting those markets by commute. A town 20 miles away with a direct motorway link may be a better source of candidates than one ten miles away with no public transport at 6am. Useful factors include travel time at shift start and finish, the cost of the journey and completion rates from candidates at different distances.
A manufacturing client in Ontario, Canada, took this approach, expanding its targeting into secondary markets weighted by commute. The improved targeting helped increase completed applications by 130% and reduce cost per apply start by 54%.
Measure Each Location Through to the Hire
More applications don’t necessarily mean more hires, and a lower cost per application doesn’t necessarily mean better recruitment performance. A multi-site plan needs measures that follow each location from spend through to hire, covering apply starts per job, completion rate, viable applications, interviews, offers and hires, alongside time to fill and open requisitions.
Operational measures complete the picture. Agency spend, unfilled shifts and vacancy days by location connect recruitment investment to outcomes the wider business already recognises, and they help operations leaders support the plan. Our blog on why dashboards and hiring managers so often disagree looks at how to bring those views together.
The data will rarely be perfect, and it doesn’t need to be. A useful habit is to separate what you know from what you don’t, identify where performance is breaking down and agree what to change first. Our guide to measuring recruitment marketing from spend to hire covers this in more detail.
A Multi-Site Planning Checklist
The table below brings the method together as a set of questions to answer before each planning cycle.
| Step | Question to answer | Owner |
| Demand | How many hires does each location need, and by when? | TA, Operations |
| Supply | How readily do local candidates respond at each location? | TA, Recruitment Marketing |
| Tiering | Which locations are self-sufficient, and which are critical? | TA |
| Budget | Does spend follow hiring need, or does it follow easy volume? | TA, Finance |
| Separation | Which locations need a dedicated campaign, and is media the real constraint? | TA, Location managers |
| Measurement | Can we track each location from spend through to hire? | TA, Analytics |
How Yoke Helps Multi-Site Employers
The findings in this guide come straight from the client data we review, and our work carries on well past the recommendation. Depending on what the data shows, we tier locations by difficulty to fill, rebalance budget towards the locations with the greatest operational need and write job content that speaks to each local market. We build dedicated campaigns and commute-weighted targeting for the hardest locations, improve apply journeys and use conversational AI and automation to speed up follow-up. Connected reporting then tracks every location from spend through to hire.
Proactive, ongoing optimisation sits behind all of it. Our team continually analyses performance location by location, challenges the status quo and looks for the next opportunity, so the technology and the budget stay focused on viable candidates, hires, filled shifts and less reliance on agency staff. We are also willing to say plainly when more media spend isn’t the answer, and sometimes the right move is to keep the budget exactly as it is and fix something further down the hiring process.
Yoke was founded by five former Indeed executives, and a lot of our work is with employers hiring across many locations, including nursery groups, retailers, manufacturers and logistics businesses. That ongoing optimisation comes together with impartial expertise, deep knowledge of Indeed and pay-for-performance advertising and sophisticated recruitment technology. Our blog on the three hiring decisions your recruitment platform can’t make for you explains how we combine the two.
Start With a Hiring Performance Review
A free Hiring Performance Review shows where your national strategy and your local reality have drifted apart, location by location. We analyse your data, identify the opportunities and present our findings and recommendations, and then help you put the changes in place. Much of the ongoing optimisation that follows can be delivered through our no-cost managed service. Get in touch to arrange your review.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is multi-site hiring performance?
Multi-site hiring performance is how well an employer turns recruitment spend into hires at each of its locations. It looks past national averages to show which locations fill roles easily, which struggle and whether budget is going where hiring need is greatest.
Can the same job perform differently in different locations?
The same employer, offering the same job at the same salary, can get very different results from one location to the next. Local labour markets, competition, candidate availability and operational requirements all shape how hard a role is to fill.
How many tiers should we use?
Three or four tiers suit most estates. Fewer than three tends to blur the difference between steady and stretched locations, while more than four makes the plan harder to manage without adding much insight.
How often should locations be re-tiered?
A quarterly review works for most employers, with a monthly check on budget allocation. Locations facing fast-moving local change, such as a new competitor opening nearby, may need attention sooner.
Should hard-to-fill locations always receive more budget?
Hard-to-fill locations often need more support, but the first step is to understand why they are hard to fill. Pay, shift patterns, the apply journey and follow-up speed can all hold hiring back, and extra media spend won’t solve those problems on its own.
Does this approach work for US employers?
The method works the same way in the US as in the UK. Retailers with hundreds of stores, logistics businesses running distribution centres and healthcare providers with multiple hospitals all face the same gap between national averages and local hiring reality.





